Try before you buy. A few may not be just right for you, True Autumn, but most should be darn good.
Check eBay for discontinueds.
Please add any info you have in the Comments.
Clinique Creamy Nude.
Clinique Crushed Grape
Clinique Golden Brandy
Clinique Metallic Sand (may be light)
Clinique Paprika (may not be perfect)
Clinique Pure Posh
Clinique Sassy Spice
Clinique Spiced Apple
Clinique Sugared Grapefruit
Clinique Sunset Glow
Cover Girl Bronzed Glow
Cover Girl Delish
Cover Girl Fervor
Cover Girl Temptation
Cover Girl Toasted Almond
Elizabeth Arden Autumn
Elizabeth Arden Perfect Currant.
Estee Lauder Amber Glaze Gloss Stick
Estee Lauder Burnished Bronze
Estee Lauder Cinnamon
Estee Lauder Hot Copper
Estee Lauder Tiger Eye (may be light)
Givenchy's Rouge Interdit lipstick in Fruity Orange
GOSH Soft 'n' Shine Balm in Mocha (discontinued in the UK?)
Jane Fardon Copper
Lancome Couture Suede
Lancome Creme De Marron
Lancome Lux lipstick in Cherrywood
Lancome Hotspell gloss
Laura Mercier Cinnamon
Loreal Rich Topaz
Mac Chili Matte (some find too red-orange)MAC Pro Longwear Lipcreme Sweet Ever After
MAC Creme In Your Coffee
Mac HoneyFlower Lustre
MAC Plushglass in Big Baby
MAC Ramblin' Rose ( Per Christine: "Ramblin Rose is an option for a peachier/coral look, but unlikely to be your day wear.")
Mac Sheen Can't Resist
MAC Sheen Supreme Look at Her
MAC Stay in Touch
MAC Strength
Max Factor Amber
Max Factor Copper Penny
Max Factor Touch of Gold (may be light)
Revlon ColorBurst Lipstick Rosy Nude
Revlon High Beam Tan
Revlon Liquid Lipstick Maximum Mocha
Revlon Sandalwood Beige
Stila Treasure