The short answer is yes.
The more complicated answer is that not every single color in your palette will look good in every application. For example, my Soft Autumn tan isn't great on me as a shirt, because that's the same color as my skin and it makes me look naked. (Generally, wearing tops or bottoms in the same color as your skin tone is a non-starter for daytime, because of the "nude" effect. Go a few shades lighter or darker.) But my SA tan is great for me in makeup, and as an accent color. My lightest pink isn't my best lippie, because it's lighter than my lips, but it's pretty as lingerie. Consider, also, your style identity: certain hues make certain impressions, and you 'll want to make an impression that's consistent with your personal style. For example, because I'm an Ethereal Natural, the majority of my wardrobe consists of Soft Autumn browns, blues, greens, gentle metallics, and dawn/dusk hues. I rarely wear my Soft Autumn pinks in large blocks because the impression they create is more girly than I am. (Though I love my pinks as lipsticks and blushes.) I almost never wear a large block of my Soft Autumn red, because the impression it makes is more aggressive than I am. (Though, again, I would wear it in makeup.) A Soft Autumn with a lot of Ingenue would want to focus on those pinks. And a Soft Autumn with a lot of Dramatic would look great in big blocks of Soft Autumn red. Check out your style type's Shopping Guide for more information about which colors from your seasonal palette to focus on. And if you're not sure about your seasonal palette, consider trying the Home Draping Cards; a lot of women have found them helpful. If you know your season, are there particular colors that you've found you can only wear in certain applications? Or if you know your style type, are there particular colors that you've found best fit with your overall vibe? Please share in the comments! Originally published July 2017.
31 Comments
Rosetta
7/17/2017 05:46:37 am
"Not every single color in your palette will look good in every application" - a very good insight, reminder & a voice of reason, thanks for that! :)
Reply
W.
7/30/2018 01:23:47 pm
How interesting! My best colors were what helped me find my style ID.
Reply
AM
7/30/2018 06:04:47 pm
Great points and similar to me! Mixing Ingenue into opposite IDs (like N and D) can also mask it. I think too that, if determining your ID has been super challenging, but you generally look good in a lot of clothes that are not from IDs that are definite no's (for me, R and G, and some N), it can be important to take a break from obsessive analysis and go out and try to see yourself in clothes and see what works in reality. It was more helpful for me to determine that I have no R, despite my figure being able to carry a lot of R looks, and no/little G and not much N, than it was to try to exactly pinpoint where I do fall. And the masculine/feminine balance - though I think my self-consciousness about some features convinced me I was perhaps more masculine than I actually am. I frankly don't think I make an impression that is uber-specific, which I see as a blessing - depending on my styling I can appear as I wish to appear (just not as an uber-sexy mature woman and not as a little boy, haha, and if I wear much N I look lost/stranded/in need of help). Since I've trained my eye to identify if a piece is harmonizing with my lines and colors, I often go based on instinct - it's after the fact that I often notice said pieces often have a lot of C, D, and maybe some I. But sometimes pieces appear to have other influences and still work for some reason. Maybe Rachel would be able to tell me why a particular piece that is "contrary" to my ID works, but for the time being - I just trust my eye. Not everyone is going to be easily categorized, and even once you are categorized, your category might not correspond to an easily identifiable style - which is freeing, as you can define your own, which everyone kind of has to do anyway because our proportions of IDs will naturally differ.
Reply
Miranda
7/30/2018 06:53:20 pm
I think I confused the pretty in Ethereal and Ingenue too - after all the agonizing, in Rachel's analysis, I turned out to have zero Ingenue and only a dash of Natural (REG). I think I was also mistaking the youthfulness and masculinity of Gamine for a blend of Natural and Ingenue. While I was trying to figure it out on my own, I initially rejected Gamine in part because I don't feel comfortable in my sparkly EGN high tops, but in reality, they don't work because they're not formal enough.
Reply
Shawna
8/3/2018 09:10:21 pm
Your comment about about mistaking Gamine for a blend of Natural and Ingenue intrigues me because I keep thinking I have N and I but people really like me in a pixie cut and that could be G. It's not D, I do know that. D is terrible on me and so is all my hair pulled back. It has to be a soft pixie. Now I am worried that I could be Ethereal Gamine Ingenue! LOL
Katja
7/31/2018 08:17:14 am
W, An Ingenue looks girly, pretty and innocent. She is very feminine, but not in a sexy way. Her figure is gently curved, but it is more trim than lush. She has wide-set eyes, a large forehead and round cheeks. She has small bones.The Ingenue woman often has curly hair. She is delicate and detailed. That is why she needs a lot of small details around her face. Headbands, bows, dots and tiny flowers read as Ingenue. You can think of the Romantic woman as a rose at the peak of blossom and the Ingenue woman as a rosebud.
Reply
W.
7/31/2018 02:04:33 pm
Hi Katja,
Shawna
8/3/2018 09:05:24 pm
Interesting to read your comments as I can kind of relate. When I did the ID calculator and first got ERI but others here said no, you can't be that, I don't see that in you. I played more and could make ENC work so left it at that for awhile. I wasn't sure of my colours but I thought I was an Autumn and had been told so by an online colour analysis. But it didn't work for me and I began to think I was a Spring. I admired Light Spring but didn't think I could wear it until I began to really pay attention to what colours were best on me and now I think I actually am a Light Spring-coral, light aqua, light lime green, light golden camel and light yellows are some of my best colours. As far as style ID goes the Ethereal seems really certain but I still keep thinking there is something Ingenue there and I know I pull off Ingenue styles. It's a bit confusing when I am tall and 51 years old but it is what works. Natural only works for me in terms of relaxed lines, though they have to be body skimming. I can't do the textures or weight of Natural and it's really only where Natural and Ethereal kind of overlap that I can do Natural. I do suit a lot of detail near my face-lace, embroidery, beading, a ruffle or two. With Kibbe I dabbled in Soft Classic and Soft Natural. but I never seemed to really fit anywhere properly and I suspect he would make me a Flamboyant Natural and I'd be miserable. While I don't think Dressing Your Truth is an effective programme. I am essentially a type 1/2 in that system. Minus some of the silly looking stuff. Like you I ranked EI boards highly when I did the ID calculator and I am tall-5' 9 1/2". I see the differences between Ethereal and Ingenue as mostly showing up in dresses-E being long and body skimming, I being more body obscuring although very short dresses are possible with E and not expected for I. Sometimes E and I seem opposite to me and I'm not sure how one would work out wearing both. I think of E as Grecian gown and I as fluffy baby-doll dresses but as you say, that's more their pure version.
Reply
Katja
8/5/2018 02:55:36 am
Shawna, I think you are a Summer. I don't know which one.
Shawna
8/5/2018 03:25:21 pm
Katja, I once thought I was a summer too. Definitely not True Summer. I tried Soft Summer but it's too grey and drab. My best colours are a peachy golden camel, peach/coral/salmon, light aqua and yellow greens. Light Summer probably isn't the worst palette I could wander into but Light Spring is better. :-)
KC
7/30/2018 01:49:55 pm
Dawn and dusk colors sound interesting for an Ethereal, especially for one with a darker Season. What hues would create a dawn/dusk impression?
Reply
Miranda
7/30/2018 06:46:26 pm
I have always felt that I can't do Ethereal colors, even though people gave me a lot of compliments when I wore them. There is a picture of me when I was a kid wearing a light blue shirt and I was barely visible in the picture - I looked like I blended into the sky. Now I think people thought those colors were pretty in comparison to colors that were too Natural, too masculine, or the wrong season (like black).
Reply
KC
8/1/2018 03:56:33 pm
Judging by the pics of Gamine faces on Rachel’s style boards, G makeup tends to emphasize the most animated and expressive facial features—eyes, brows, and mouth. The overall effect gives the impression of a cartoon character or an emoji. G makeup sees to consist of well-defined brows, lips that are MLBB or a couple shades brighter, and eyes defined with eyeliner and mascara but practically invisible shadow. The right blush could lend an air of youth and energy, but blush doesn’t seem to be emphasized for this style ID. Since you also have R and E, you could add a fair amount of shimmer to the basic G template and get a more dressy, formal look that way. Hope this was helpful :).
Reply
Christy
7/31/2018 06:32:07 am
I find the combination of colors and style really challenging. I am closest to being a Dark Autumn, but when I bought Rachel’s color swatches, there are several colors in there that are too warm and too muted for me. I had a personal color analysis done elsewhere sometime back, which narrowed by best colors in the DA spectrum, eliminating golds and muted oranges.
Reply
AM
7/31/2018 10:20:41 am
Yes to the work not being finished once you have identified your colors and lines - in some ways, it just begins!
Reply
Rachel
7/31/2018 01:12:07 pm
Hi! I’m still working on these durn makeup guides — part of the reason they are taking so long is I am solving mysteries as I write them. For that reason, I so appreciate hearing your feedback about what lipstick does to your face. Deep lipstick also makes me look rather masculine as well. Yes it can be quite good for both Romantics and Dramatics.
AM
7/31/2018 03:15:43 pm
No rush! Looking forward to the guides. I have personally found that, not only do bold lips/visible lipstick make me look masculine, overdone lashes are bad too. Particularly lashes with a lot of volume in the middle as opposed to the outer lashes, if that makes sense. Cat eyes are awesome for me, though, as long as they are in SA colors (tough for liquid liner, I usually go with a pencil as a result but overly smudgy makeup is also NOT for me, I just look dirty). I can also do a "fresh" look with no eye makeup/just subtle taupe eyeliner with the wing "extending" the eye, with more emphasis on a peachy blush that's applied toward the upper part of the face. Brow emphasis is good, I have naturally sparse brows but can't seem to really overdo the brows so long as the color is right. Matte is good, or just a tinted sunscreen that isn't too dewy. But some cheekbone dewiness is good. My eyes are too hooded for playful eyeshadow, though I do like a visible taupe or gold shadow - that looks good. Contour usually looks dirty - my bones stick out without doing anything, and trying to contour the parts with more baby fat just looks fake. I have been beginning to apply a rosy nude blush as a contour on non-puffy days, and I suspect as I get older contour will work better for me. Highlighting is great for bringing out bone structure in photos. Absolutely no makeup is not fantastic. Too unpolished. But too much R sort of makeup is worse. I can take a lot of makeup in the right colors, but it's better if it has an almost editorial, totally nonsexual vibe. And I always need some restraint - single feature emphasis is good. One of the times I was lucky enough to have a famous makeup artist do my makeup at a department store event, he did what I would describe as a very "Hunger Games" formal look - intense charcoal eyes with metallics, extending all the way up to the brow, with very subtle peachy blush/contour, matte foundation, and very subtle matte peachy lips. It was the greatest makeup ever - I felt so sad when I had to take it off!
Shawna
8/3/2018 09:19:03 pm
I really struggled with makeup until I decided I am a Light Spring. I am a warm leaning LSp so I can wear a lot of warmth and even Autumn or True Spring makeup looks unexpectedly right in terms of colour but is so heavy I look like a child playing dress up. I need sheer lipstick to look normal and light colours though sometimes they get too chalky looking. I think that's possibly a formula issue again though. Too thick and matte is bad! More than other cosmetics I find lipstick quite telling too.
KC
8/1/2018 03:43:26 pm
Actually, large and well-defined blocks of red work well for Dramatics. And judging from pics I’ve seen, a classic red lip looks very appropriate on DC combos. If you love red lips, maybe try incorporating your E elsewhere in your makeup, like highlighting/strobing or a light, shimmery eyeshadow.
Reply
Christy
8/2/2018 07:47:13 pm
I want to point out that I can’t say enough good things about Rachel’s work. What she is saying makes so much sense. The problem is that the world does not necessarily accept all style type/color season combos equally. Since my two biggest essences are otherworldly, I should not find it surprising that what works for me in a purely objective sense is a bit off putting. I just would love to express all of my essences all of the time, and it does not seem that that concept fits with the world’s expectations.
Reply
Alex
8/3/2018 08:31:57 am
"I am closest to being a Dark Autumn, but...there are several colors in there that are too warm and too muted for me."
Reply
Alex
8/1/2018 04:00:45 pm
Oh, this is fascinating!
Reply
Megan
8/2/2018 11:10:34 am
I can’t complain about my style ID/color palette harmony—Bright Winter Romantic Dramatic is pretty harmonious. The "femme fatale" vibe is not always harmonious with my lifestyle, but that’s a different issue!
Reply
Christy
8/3/2018 07:21:41 pm
In reviewing Rachel’s discussions of makeup, Ds should emphasize either the eye or the lip. Like you, Megan, I can do the dark eye/nude lip, but I need some kind of balance with a dark lip. I honestly don’t know if that is just cultural conditioning, or it really looks better, but I don’t feel pretty with just lip emphasis.
Reply
Megan
8/4/2018 01:55:14 pm
That's interesting to think that it might be cultural conditioning that prevents us from feeling good with only lip emphasis... I think I'll continue to experiment and see if I can make some sort of dark lip/unemphasized eye combo.
Ignacia
8/4/2018 07:50:58 pm
I’m TA or DA with pale skin; light golden brown hair, eyebrows and lashes; and brown eyes that seem pretty dark compared to the rest of my colouring. I’m also sure that I have a lot of ingenue and classic (perhaps with a dash of natural or ethereal).
Reply
Megan
8/5/2018 11:25:04 am
Hi Ignacia, I would say only add Romantic to your look if your face has Romantic lines. Maybe you do have some Romantic and that's part of why you look good in red?
Reply
Christy
8/5/2018 12:28:13 pm
I did have a question about the color wardrobes for the seasons. I had studied the Dark Autumn palettes put out by Color Me Beautiful both in the U.S. and the U.K., and there is some overlap between the 12 seasons. I purchased Rachel's card for Dark Autumn and Soft Autumn (I believe my daughter is a soft autumn), and the cards seem to be somewhat incomplete? For instance, reading through the list of colors available to me there are 67 colors listed for Dark Autumn, but there are only 42 color cards. There are some obvious shades missing from the cards, like black. I have not really studied Sci/Art or 12 Blueprints, but I get the impression that perhaps the basic shades I get, like black, charcoal and navy, may vary from season to season. Should I assume that the colors that are missing from the cards are so common that I don't need templates for them? That is what I have been doing, but I find it interesting that the makeup guides seem to follow the card colors and not include those basic shades. I also noticed that the Soft Autumn cards included what I consider charcoal and pewter, but Dark Autumn didn't. I hope I haven't misunderstood, as I continue to use what I believe to be navy, black, and charcoal.
Reply
Jo
8/6/2018 02:00:10 pm
I definitly cannot have orange and red lipstick - bo th on TSp palette but the only one good for me is light coral. I can have only one colour of lipstick. Rachel, does it happen among TSp?
Reply
Christy
8/11/2018 05:35:51 pm
Ok, so I need to admit that I have been wrong about some of the colors that do and don’t work for me. I finally took the time to really drape myself with the color analysis I previously did, Rachel’s DA cards and th SA cards I got for my daughter. (I had this idea from the books I had read that now that I am over 50 and dye my hair, I may “become” SA. Not really the Sci/Art approach, but I am still learning.) i focused on my skin, and——-this is critical——took pictures of myself in different lights. In ALL of the lights Rachel’s DA cards were the best with my skin. No contest. The pictures revealed, as they often do, things I could not clearly see with the naked eye. I still think some of the colors are not my best, and I still have questions about the colors that appear on my written list, but are not included in the cards, but undoubtedly worth the investment.
Reply
Alexis
8/28/2024 06:36:25 pm
I got draped last year and found out I'm a true winter. I noticed during the draping that the jewel tones in my palette--especially the reds, pinks, purples, and blues--are by far my most flattering. I know jewel tones read as romantic, but I think I'm a blend. Maybe with some ingenue, because the light, icy pink was very good on me too.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
About Me...I'm passionate about helping people become their most authentic and beautiful selves. Categories
All
|