Reveal your true beauty with personal color analysis (PCA) and personal style analysis.

Revising Our Idea of What Spring and Summer Look Like

3/24/2011

33 Comments

These women have two things in common.

1. They're all famous Springs.

Charlize Theron

Nicole Kidman

Scarlett Johansson

2. They're all brunettes.

Young Charlize has brown hair. Her new growth in the 2nd picture is also brown.

Young Nicole has warm brown hair with some natural highlight. Her new growth in the 2nd picture is also a warm brown.

Young Scarlett has light brown hair with some natural highlights. Her new growth in the 2nd picture is also brown.

Their Springiness may help these particular women be convincing blondes. But like most adult American women with blonde hair, their natural hair color is actually brown.

I bring this up because we deceive ourselves about blondeness, and in doing so we deceive ourselves about seasonal color.

We want to believe in blondeness. So we smile and nod when celebs claim they're "natural blondes" and we ignore the evidence in front of our eyes.

(I think celebs have all agreed to privately define "naturally blonde" as "blonde at birth" or "blonde during some period of my childhood." One's childhood hair color is not one's natural color if one is no longer a child.)

Articles like this one perpetuate this peculiar, false faith in the supposed natural blondeness of brown-haired celebs. It doesn't take a lot of research to determine that Angelina, Brittany, Gwyneth, etc. have been natural brunettes at least since adolescence, if not longer.

OK, so what? Why do I care?

Well, partly because belief in the myth of widespread natural blondeness perpetuates an idealization of light coloring that's hurtful to darker women, especially because the context is a society that already privileges Whiteness in so many ways.

Partly because of my nature: I'm an Enneagram 4. I want to reveal the truth.

And partly - and most pertinently, for this blog - because seeing all these supposedly blonde Spring and Summer celebs leads us to incorrectly believe that Springs and Summers - especially Light Springs and Summers, and Warm Springs - are typically blonde.

I personally know many brunettes whose path to discovering their true colors was made longer and more difficult because of a shared, mistaken belief that certain Spring and Summer seasons are blonde seasons.

There is no blonde season. Every season's average or typical representative is a natural brunette.

Statistically, it's inevitable that this be the case; with the vast majority of all human beings having naturally brown or black hair, a majority of even the most delicately-colored people will be brunette as well.

It's true that natural blondeness is not found infrequently in the seasons with lighter palettes, in particular Light Summer and Light Spring.

Might a quarter, or even a third, of adult Light Summers or Light Springs have blonde hair growing naturally from their heads? Perhaps. You can think of dozens of Light-season people as easily as I can. What proportion of them are blonde at age 30?

Surely not the majority of them. Probably not even half of them.

Let's revise our mental image of what these seasons look like. The caricatures just get in the way of seeing what's real. We know it's not about hair color anyway, so let's picture what it's really about. Look at the Light and Warm Springs and Light Summers that you know: what do you really see?

Light Spring Scarlett's natural hair color now might resemble this.

It's probably not this warm, but Warm Spring Cameron Diaz's natural shade may be about this deep.

This color may be similar to Warm Spring Charlize's natural color.

Light Summer Gwyneth as a teen. (Lip is too orange, though, no?)

Light Summer Reese as a teen.

This could be close to Michelle Pfeiffer's natural color.

P.S. Blonde sisters, I hope it doesn't sound like I'm hating on you. You're beautiful and I love you. I just like to keep it real.

P.P.S. Scandinavians, I realize what I've written here might not reflect your reality. I know there is an unusual proportion of natural blondes in your little corner of the world. :-)

*******************************************************************
Postscript, 3/30/11:

Here is a hair color scale I originally intended to use in the post above, to help make clear how I'm personally defining "blonde" and "brown."
In the end, it felt pedantic to include it - but now I think the failure to attempt to define terms just added to the general chaos. So for the record, this graphic reflects how I was conceptualizing these hair colors when I wrote the post. For me, it was essentially a question of hue: more yellow than brown = blonde, more brown than yellow = brunette.

33 Comments

Ashley link

3/24/2011 01:09:01 pm

*applauds* Bravo. I'm glad another person has addressed this.

Relatable Style link

3/24/2011 01:47:47 pm

Wow. I kinda feel special now :-)

<a href="http://www.relatablestyle.blogspot.com">Relatable Style</a>

colorqueen

3/24/2011 06:04:14 pm

This is a great article. What I would really love to see is an article that discusses how you would decide if a brunette is a spring or an autumn (if warm) or a summer or winter (if cool). What sort of tests show the borderline ones... For example, we might think the brunette spring is an autumn by default, but what clues should we look for? We might think the dark brunette summer is a winter, but how can we tell if she is or not? I'm talking about the brunettes that don't fit obvious categories... that would be fascinating! Really enjoyed the article by the way! Great stuff!

Rachel

3/25/2011 03:25:35 am

Hi, colorqueen -

I don't subscribe to the school of thought that believes physical characteristics can predict season, so the tests I'd recommend would look at how the brunette's skin reacts to color.

There are a few colors that can sometimes distinguish between Spring & Autumn or Summer & Winter. A bright yellow-green, for example, will often brighten up a Spring but look indifferent or downright unattractive on an Autumn. Unrelieved, pure black can make a Winter look healthy but overwhelm a Summer.

Any method short of draping runs the risk of being inaccurate, but I suggest some things to try here:
http://www.truth-is-beauty.com/what-season-are-you.html

Good luck. :-)

Helen

3/25/2011 05:56:06 am

Hooray!! Great article, it's so easy to fall into the trap of only blondes are springs. I tried for years to be a soft autumn unsuccessfully wondering why the colours were just too dark and heavy for me. I'm still trying to find lipsticks soft enough and light enough because I reach so autumatically for the browns.

3/26/2011 01:18:57 pm

:) Yay! Very brunette neutral-warm spring here.
I'm glad you posted this article, as redheads are also largely 'acceptable' as springs (and summers) now, but not much has been written about the ones with darker brunette hair.

I've always been the 'dark' sister in the midst of my blonde sisters. The "rose red" character. Thought for ages that I must be a cool season or something 'dark'/deep because of my contrasting hair and skin (which is delicate/porcelain), but nothing ever fit right. My flushed cheeks probably should have been a good first indicator for spring though (exactly like the young Nicole Kidman picture you posted!). ;) But yeah, it was difficult coming around to the idea that I was a spring, though I'm so glad I did. And I like being an example that it's 'possible'.

The only brunette spring (who isn't often blonded) I can think of right now is Rose McGowan. Her natural hair color in this photo is the same as mine: http://x17online.com/RmcGowan100108_02_X17.jpg

Thanks again for the article! :)

Divalicious

3/27/2011 01:14:28 am

@E : in that picture, Rose McGowan looks more like a deep winter than spring to me...

Hanna

3/27/2011 03:46:37 am

Even in Scandinavia most of the (light) blondes you see are either not blonde at all or are really a darker shade of blonde. Which is another thing I find confusing: why do people only call the lightest shades of blonde 'blonde'?

For instance, on Pretty your world's hair colour page the first picture under Brown/brunette is Kristin Dunst in what I would call blonde, and not even very dark blonde. Calista Flockhart looks light brown to me, but I could see a dark blonde being as dark haired, or at least nearly, as Vanessa Minnillow just a different colour.

Maybe I just see it differently than most but to me the difference between blonde and brown is not just light vs dark but a difference in hue as well. Growing up one of my sisters was always called brown-haired while I was called blonde but looking at old pictures her hair wasn't really all that much darker than mine it was just browner.

3/27/2011 10:40:47 am

Diva: well, I won't argue it much, though she's said to be a bright spring? So there could be some winter cross-over. It might be the sun/shade combo that make her look so translucent, and the warm red coral dress might be better on a warm spring. But her hair color in the sun is the same as mine. That's more the point I wanted to get at from the photo. People don't seem to think warm springs would have dark auburn hair, it's an unfair assumption, which is why I was confused for quite a while because I didn't -look- uber-warm like that even though I am.

Kalulu

3/27/2011 05:55:59 pm

It is hard for me to get my mind around the term "brunette" being tossed about so loosely. I am no true blonde even though I'm a Light Spring, but "brunette"? No one has ever called me such a thing in my entire life. This is a word normally reserved for people with truly dark hair and features. Judging by the usage on the Internet the lack of distinction is a recent and growing phenomenon, possibly defensible by the etymological origins of the word. But even so it leaves a gap in the nomenclature.

Having gotten that off my chest, I am glad that you addressed the issue of what color hair is possible with the lighter seasons. It certainly did make it incredibly difficult to fit into a season!

Tyyne

3/29/2011 03:58:25 am

Greetings from Finland!

I love your blog, Rachel. You are very talented! Do you think you would be able to post a blog post about true winter vs summer, or just about true winter? I have been diagnosed by 6 different analysts as both true winter and true summer. Everyone have depended on my looks... I like both palettes, but I don't know which is "mine" and not... I would love your input on things, and I would love seeing some celeb examples that aren't stereotypical summer or winter... I have a Norwegian friend who's in the same boat as me, but she feels most at home in the winter colors even though she admits she looks more like a summer w/o makeup than a winter. However none of us suscribe to that "eye color + hair color + skin color = that season"... Do you believe in true season blonds (true winter - true summer blend, true autumn true spring blend)?

-Tyyne

Rachel

3/30/2011 01:48:14 am

Tynne - thank you. :-) I'll add your idea to my list of future post topics.

Hanna, and others - we do need to define our terms, don't we? It's a failing of mine in this post, though I think it reflects a general vagueness in the language available for talking about women's real bodies, and perhaps a cultural unwillingness to look closely at their subtleties...?

When I started writing this, I actually had a graphic ready to put in - a hair color scale - that I intended to use as a starting point to define "blonde" & "brown" - but ultimately it felt nitpicky to me. In retrospect, I think it might have made things easier for everyone. Perhaps I should add it as a postscript...

3/30/2011 09:22:18 am

The post script helped. :) Am definitely somewhere in 3 Dark Brown.

Kalulu

4/1/2011 06:02:56 pm

Definitely helped. Personally, I fall into the med-dark blonde range, though it's what many term "light brown". The thought of being a brunette was so foreign to me, but I think people are starting to use the term for anything non-no. 8-12.

Leiu

2/28/2017 05:58:35 pm

I also do not see myself as a brunette and so do an awful lot of people who have a similar colour like me and don't dye their hair. This picture is from a thread of people with long hair who were searching for people with ash dark blond hair.
https://www.google.com/search?q=light+blonde&client=firefox-a&hs=qxw&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=fflb&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=BVTpUon4E6_JsQTn_IKADQ&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1267&bih=550#channel=fflb&q=blonde&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=isch
Actually I'm a bit confused to see that Scarlett's hair is considered brunette.

Tora

5/2/2011 10:15:50 pm

It always seemed like a really big deal that I was blonde because my parents and older sister were brunette. It didn't help that I was blue-eyed and my sister hazeled so I typified the "ideal" that was in every children's cartoon in the 80s (and everywhere else). She-Ra, Barbie, Jem, even the Care-Bears movie. My family all made a big deal out of it for as long as I could remember so it was this huge part of my identity. As a teen I started using Sun-in because I wasn't playing in the sun like I used to and it wasn't lightening up much on its own. By 17 it was definitely dirty blonde roots so I started dying it blonder. At 20 I had chopped most of my hair off and once it grew out some inches, it felt sooo dark, about the color of Scarlett's hair in the pic. And everyone said I looked so much better with blonde.

In fall 2009 I read this book called Going Gray as I was contemplating giving into my natural color. It assured me I don't want to be one of those women who was still dying at 60. Even if it starts graying at 30 I can deal =P The book (good book) mentioned Color Me A Season and that's how it all started.

My hair is a bit darker now, like Charlize's pic except ashier. And because of the "mousiness" (a hair color word I think is evil), and softness...flatness really, I talked myself into being a Soft Summer. I figured that whatever season I was, my "new" hair color would look right and my family and friends would stop with their comments. I looked "good" in black because my bright blonde hair was a nice contrast. But it was only about seeing the hair, not seeing me.

When I finally got a PCA done a year ago, I was sooo happy to find I was a Light Summer instead. My lifelong preferred colors were always brighter than SS, sometimes lighter so I've been really pleased with my swatch. Now my "mousy" dark blonde/light brown hair, whatever anyone wants to call it, looks so fantastic with my right colors. It provides my face with much needed contrast and compliments my eye color nicely.

As far as color terms go... I've laid my hair against drugstore hair colors boxes, the sides that say "if your color is this, it will become this" and it matches neutral to ash dark blonde. It just doesn't seem to have the warmth or oranginess of the light browns. But yeah, people will call it whatever they like. I consider Kirsten Dunst to have dirty/honeyed blonde hair on PYW's hair page too. I just wish "brunette" didn't refer to both brown-hair AND black-hair. When I was a kid I thought brunettes had brown hair but it was annoying to find out that Courtney Cox's hair color was in the same group as Jennifer Aniston's. And light brown hair is more similar to blonde hair than black hair...

There is a nice chart here
http://www.hairstylesguru.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/red-haircolor-chart.jpg

Scarlett needs to get her natural color back. The blonde on her makes me cringe. I even like the bottle red of Lost in Translation better.

Lou

5/23/2011 03:19:14 am

I'm glad someone finally made this point! Quite frankly, I've never seen a celebrity spring who's NOT a brunette, or at least very dark blonde.
And since I am Scandinavian myself, I can assure anyone that 95 % of all so called blondes in Scandinavia color their hair. Usually only children are platina blonde.
I am one of those few people who still as an adult has light blonde hair. And people always want to put me in the spring category, or summer, based on my lightness! But I have always felt most comfortable in autumn colors, and receive most compliments then. And when I had a very well done color analysis I actually ended up being an autumn. Put me in olive green, brown or rust, and my green eyes will glow! Spring colors are too clear, they overpower me and wash me out...
So, to summon up, I just wanted to say that people's color season isn't based on their hair color.
Best regards, from a light blonde soft autumn : )

Kirsten

9/16/2011 04:19:06 pm

Thank you for your article "exploding" the blonde myth! It was easy for me to identify myself as a Summer, but impossible for me to identify myself as a "dominant characteristic" type because my hair color seemed to fit only the Soft type. I've found that I look my best in Light colors--and so does my hair in its natural ashy color. I went through a spell of having it highlighted but now I'm saving myself the expense and enjoying my true coloring. But there's still such pressure to go blonde, so your article makes me feel vindicated!

Rachel

1/18/2013 05:00:00 am

Thank you for such an informative article! I originally assumed I was a Winter because my hair looked dark to me. I'm still unsure of my season, and I can't find anyone in town that does draping. Two hairstylists have told me my hair is a level 7 dark blonde ash color. I'm wondering--can a Bright Spring have ash colored hair, or is warmth always present in their hair coloring? My eyes have some warmth in them, but my skin has some pink in it. My veins are mostly blue with some green mixed in. Any help is appreciated.

Rachel Arnt-Schemmel

2/16/2013 11:56:18 am

Rachel-

The beat advice I can give here is to suspend any judgments about what you think your hair color is. When you know the truth of your skin, and you're wearing the right colors, you'll notice tones in your hair (and eyes) that you never saw before. Also, like eyes, hair is usually not just one color. You can have one color at your roots and another at the end at yet another in the summer - and your greys add more variety still.
I guess the short answer is yes, a BSp could have hair that some call "ash." But it may not look ash-toned in the right colors.

michele link

3/6/2013 06:25:00 am

Being a TRUE high level blonde, naturally, as an adult I really appreciate you pointing out that these women are not real blondes and that most 'blonde' women aren't.

12/26/2013 08:14:00 pm

People tend to assosiate eastern europe with natural blond, I heard from Spanish friend that there are sooooo many girls with blond hair in Poland - Im telling you there arent! It happenes that they have ash blond but most of them have greyish-brown hair. Natural blond hair women is something very rare. In Sweden probably are more blondes but they have not golden but cold almost white hair, and there are also brunettes even there...NATURAL BLOND HAIR ARE RARE and awesome :) i read that only 2% of world population is natural blond but it doesnt say golden or white, i love golden blond hair

1/29/2014 05:32:25 am

The pictures you showed of Scarlett, Reese, and Michelle to me all show blonde hair, not brunette. I think the chart you used was not meant to represent actual hair color. This is a far better chart: http://killerpics.blogspot.com/2007/08/today.html

Rachel link

1/29/2014 06:31:35 am

The question of what's blonde and what's brunette may ultimately be a potato-poTAHto issue.

In my mind, the distinction between the two is similar to what's represented in the image I posted above, or in any of these charts:

http://i809.photobucket.com/albums/zz17/Blaircorneliabass/haircolorlevelchart-1-1.jpg
http://www.hairfad.com/images/hair-color-levels.png
http://vitaehair.com/yahoo_site_admin/assets/images/Vitaecolorchart.84200821.gif

Would most people really agree that the Level 6 woman on the link you posted is a blonde? I wonder. If I google "blonde," here's what I see:

https://www.google.com/search?q=light+blonde&client=firefox-a&hs=qxw&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=fflb&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=BVTpUon4E6_JsQTn_IKADQ&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1267&bih=550#channel=fflb&q=blonde&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=isch

That's yellow and light yellow hair.

Googling "light brown hair," on the other hand, gives me a lot of pics that look like the Level 6 woman on the page you linked.

https://www.google.com/search?q=light+brown&client=firefox-a&hs=OMc&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=fflb&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=9FTpUtS1JrLKsQTu4oGYCQ&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1267&bih=550#channel=fflb&q=light+brown+hair&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=isch

But, agh, how much does it actually matter how we define these terms? I suppose as long as blonde hair is considered superior, it will matter

Wherever we draw the line, what I'd hope people would take away from this article is that Summers and Springs do *not* typically look like those yellow and light yellow heads that we see when we google "blonde."

1/30/2014 05:32:20 am

I can agree that the level 6 blonde in the link I posted hardly fits with the public perception of blonde, however it is considered blonde by hair dressing standards, which may be another reason why so many celebrities say that they are naturally blonde. My opinion is that level 6 is split down the middle; I've seen it in blonde form and I've seen it brown. Also, I am the creator of the hair color chart you linked to. :) http://i809.photobucket.com/albums/zz17/Blaircorneliabass/haircolorlevelchart-1-1.jpg

Rachel

1/30/2014 05:54:04 am

Wow! That's a neat chart. :-)

I think this conversation, like a lot of conversations about word definitions, comes down to this: Does a word mean what experts say it means, or does a word mean what most people believe it means?

1/30/2014 11:08:47 am

I can definitely agree with that. :) As your article suggests, I believe we see far too many representations of bleached light blonde, so much so that we only think of that color when thinking of blonde. Whereas the majority of blonde adults are almost all medium-dark blondes. Anyway, thanks for writing the article!

2/26/2014 08:42:19 pm

Thank you! This post was very clearifying for me. I have light brown hair (much like young Scarlett or Nicole), blue eyes and bright, but still warm skin. I always thought (and heard from others) "springs are blond". I have tried to squeeze me in to the summer or autumn section, but I basically look sick in many of the blue and cold colors typical for soft summer for example. And autumn colors didn't seemed right either. But the bright spring palette seems much more suiting.

And btw, I live in Sweden and I think there are more adult scandinavians with dark blond/cendré/light brown hair than light blondes. I think it is a part of the same syndrome you are writing about, many scandinavian women can be convincing blondes. : )

Cal

9/22/2015 11:00:59 am

I find this very informative for the most part. However, I find it odd that you consider Scarletts hair brown and then post a professional hair level chart. Most hair stylists have called me level 7 and one called me level 6. And my hair is almost the exact color as Scarletts! I would consider her a natural dark blonde. But of course, this stuff is subjective.

Rachel Arnt-Schemmel

10/2/2015 09:35:03 am

It really is, isn't it?

erin

3/30/2016 02:03:32 pm

Thank you for this article. I am a level 7N, neutral dark blonde and I have had the hardest time figuring out that I am indeed a Spring, and probably a Light Spring at that! All I ever see on Light Spring examples are colored blonde celebrities. It makes it all so confusing!

Catherine

10/20/2016 03:32:25 pm

Excellent article, Rachel. I'm a brunette, 4.5 on the scale, and I'm also almost certainly a Spring. At least one site states that if one's hair is brown they're definite not spring. Thanks for clearing up this misconception.

Milla

1/23/2017 08:16:23 pm

Yes to this. I am definitely a light summer but have medium brown hair and medium depth hazel eyes. People assume because of this that I will look good in brown/olive green clothes, when in fact these autumn shades are the absolute worst for my skin tone. I've noticed all light summer celebrity examples have blue eyes and this has created a widespread myth that if you don't have blue eyes you cannot be a light summer or light spring.

Revising Our Idea of What Spring and Summer Look Like

Leave a Reply.

About Me...

Categories

Archives